|
|
|
||||||||||
Clinical Coordinator/Residency Program Director, Gaston Memorial Hospital, Gastonia, NC
Assistant Professor of Pharmaceutical Sciences, Department of Pharmaceutical Sciences, College of PharmacyGlendale, Midwestern University, Glendale, AZ
Reprints: Dr. Amabile, Gaston Memorial Hospital, 2525 Court Dr., Gastonia, NC 28053-1747, fax 704/834-3030, amabilec{at}gmh.org
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
DATA SOURCES: Searches of MEDLINE (1966-May 2006) and an extensive review of peer reviewed journals were conducted using the key search terms opioid, morphine, hydromorphone, and oxycodone. Supplemental information was gathered through the American Pain Society, and limited but relevant information was obtained from manufacturers' labeling.
STUDY SELECTION AND DATA EXTRACTION: All articles identified from the data sources were evaluated. Information deemed relevant was included for this review if it introduced new or well supported concepts or clarified clinical practice issues.
DATA SYNTHESIS: The recognition and treatment of pain has become a major focus of healthcare professionals. The Joint Commission on Accreditation of Healthcare Organizations mandates compliance with recommended standards, outcome measures, and other initiatives. A general review of pain management and pharmacokinetic parameters are included.
CONCLUSIONS: Oral modified-release products have enabled patients to better maintain pain control due to convenient dosing intervals and sustained blood concentrations. The differences between available oral modified-release products are half-life, cost, and formulation (excipients and drug-release properties).
Key Words: hydromorphone, morphine, opioid, oxycodone
Published Online, July 25, 2006. www.theannals.com, DOI 10.1345/aph.1G259
THIS ARTICLE IS APPROVED FOR CONTINUING EDUCATION CREDIT
ACPE UNIVERSAL PROGRAM NUMBER: 407-000-06-017-H01
This review focuses on the oral modified-release opioid products currently used to treat moderate-to-severe chronic pain: morphine (Avinza, Kadian, Oramorph, MS Contin) and oxycodone (OxyContin). These products vary in regard to their active ingredient, dosage form, mechanism of drug release, dosing frequency, pharmacokinetic profile, and cost. To effectively manage chronic pain, healthcare providers must have a complete understanding of this class of drug products. Modified-release opioid formulations have also been designed for other forms of administration (eg, transdermal fentanyl), and some oral modified-release opioid products are delivered via alternate routes (eg, rectal administration of MS Contin tablets); however, this review focuses on orally administered products. Palladone (hydromorphone), which was recently withdrawn from the market due to safety concerns, and miscellaneous products in development are included in the discussion.
The delivery systems discussed here have been designated as extended-release, controlled-release, or sustainedrelease. However, these terms do not have specific definitions and have been used inconsistently within other published reports. One needs to examine each product to determine its exact mechanism of drug release. The formulations in this review are generally referred to as modifiedrelease products.
| General Review of Opioid Analgesics |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
PHARMACOKINETICS AND PHARMACODYNAMICS
Opioids are primarily metabolized by the liver through dealkylation,
conjugation, hydrolysis, and oxidation, and their resulting metabolites
undergo renal
excretion.7
Opioids such as codeine, meperidine, and propoxyphene have pharmacologically
active
metabolites.6,9
Therefore, both hepatic and renal impairment may significantly influence the
clinical effects of many opioids. Drug interactions also occur with some
opioids. For example, codeine, oxycodone, and hydrocodone are major substrates
of CYP2D6; therefore, the blood concentrations of these opioids may be
affected by agents that inhibit or induce this
enzyme.9-11
All of the µ-opioid agonists have different pharmacokinetic properties, but all are pharmacodynamically similar. Blood concentrations of opioid agonists do not directly predict analgesic response.12,13 However, an increase in dose typically results in greater analgesia with no limit to the effect.14 Therefore, these agents do not have a defined maximum dose, and the "ceiling" to analgesic effectiveness is imposed only by ADEs, which also increase with dose.14 Effective opioid blood concentrations are dependent on several factors including a patient's age, medical condition, and previous opioid use.12,13 The minimum effective concentration varies greatly, and dosing should be based on clinical evaluation of the patient to achieve an optimal balance between therapeutic pain control and ADEs.12-14
| Equianalgesic Dosing |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
The manufacturer's package inserts for the modified-release preparation of oxycodone (OxyContin) also contains a conversion table based on multiplication factors (Table 2).12 This table has not been verified in well controlled, multiple-dose trials and underestimates the conversion of opioid dosages compared with the chart shown in Table 1. It is also important to note that the dosing factors shown in Table 2 can be used only when converting from an opioid to OxyContin (ie, not between the other opioids within the table). For example, a daily oral morphine dose can be converted to an equipotent OxyContin dose using the figures in Table 2, but morphine cannot be converted to meperidine using this table.
|
CROSS-ALLERGINICITY
The classification of opioid analgesics may be based on 3 different
schemes: (1) analog class (phenanthrene, phenylpiperidine, diphenylheptane),
(2) chemical source (natural, semisynthetic, synthetic), and (3) the presence
or absence of a morphine-related chemical structure with a 6-hydroxyl group.
The phenanthrene analog class consists of morphine, codeine, hydromorphone,
oxycodone, and hydrocodone. Meperidine and fentanyl are in the
phenyl-piperidine class; methadone and propoxyphene are in the diphenylheptane
class. Morphine and codeine are the 2 naturally occurring opioids, while
hydromorphone, oxycodone, and hydrocodone are semisynthetic. Meperidine,
fentanyl, methadone, and propoxyphene are synthetic opioids. Codeine is the
only opioid that has a morphine-related chemical structure that includes a
6-hydroxyl group.
True allergic and anaphylactic reactions to opioid analgesics are rare, and the risk of cross-sensitivity is low even between the natural and semisynthetic compounds. Available reports suggest that reactions to opioids are most often related to nonimmunologic effects (histamine release, improper dosing, or concomitant medications), and none of these cases describes cross-sensitivity.16 Histamine release has been linked to urticaria, pruritus, and sneezing in patients receiving opioids. There are no clear guidelines for patients with a reported opioid allergy. It is best to evaluate each case individually and is most often safe and necessary to administer an opioid from a nonrelated source (semisynthetic vs naturally occurring). Most of the histamine release causes pruritus, which can be treated with around-the-clock antihistamine administration prior to administering opioid doses. Since most patients develop tolerance to the pruritus, the antihistamines can be discontinued when that occurs. In some cases, changing to a different opioid may be necessary due to pruritus refractory to antihistamines.
ADVERSE DRUG EFFECTS
The ADEs of opioids result from the binding and activation of µ-opioid
receptors throughout the body (eg, CNS, gastrointestinal [GI] system). Opioids
have a low incidence of organ toxicity, and the most common opioid-induced
ADEs include sedation, confusion, pruritus, nausea and vomiting, respiratory
depression, and constipation. After repeated dosing, patients usually develop
tolerance to opioid ADEs such as sedation, pruritus, and nausea and
vomiting.15
Tolerance to respiratory depression is variable because this ADE is also dose
related. For example, opioid-naïve patients are at a higher risk of
experiencing respiratory depression; however, a patient receiving chronic
opioid therapy may also experience this ADE if a significantly higher dose is
administered. In general, patients do not develop tolerance to opioid-induced
constipation. The general approaches to managing opioid-induced ADEs include
trying a different drug, changing the dose or route of administration, adding
a drug that counteracts the effect, and considering nonpharmacologic
actions.
| Oral Modified-Release Opioid Products |
|---|
|
|
|---|
30 h) and does not require
frequent dosing. Fentanyl undergoes significant first-pass metabolism and
lacks sufficient bioavailability after oral administration. Pharmacokinetic processes such as distribution, metabolism, and excretion are difficult to manipulate consistently and predictably so as to prolong the in vivo duration of action of a therapeutic agent.2 Therefore, the only effective way of controlling blood concentration profiles is to design product formulations that modify the absorption of active ingredients into the body. Table 3 lists the brand name modified-release opioid products available for the oral treatment of pain.12,13,17-19 Generic, AB-rated products are also available for MS Contin controlled-release tablets (15, 30, 60, 100, 200 mg) and OxyContin controlled-release tablets (10, 20, 40, 80 mg). All of these brand name and generic products are categorized as Schedule II controlled substances.
|
All of the products listed in Table 3 may be taken without regard to meals. However, they are sensitive to alterations that destroy their modified-release mechanisms. Therefore, these products should be swallowed whole (ie, not broken, chewed, crushed, or dissolved) due to the risk of rapid opioid release and absorption of potentially fatal doses. For patients experiencing difficulty swallowing, capsule products such as Avinza and Kadian may be opened and their entire bead contents sprinkled onto applesauce immediately prior to administration.13,17 The applesauce should be room temperature or cooler, and the entire amount should be consumed without chewing, followed by rinsing and swallowing with water to ensure that all beads are ingested. The prescribing information for Kadian also indicates that the entire capsule contents may be administered through a 16 French gastrostomy tube.17 The prescribing information for Avinza makes no such mention.13 However, instructions for G-tube administration can be obtained from the manufacturer (telephone 888/828-4692).
In overdose situations, modified-release delivery systems may continue to release their active ingredients; therefore, the management of an overdose should be monitored accordingly. Evacuation of the gastric contents may be required to eliminate unabsorbed drug. In addition, some of the excipients used to prepare oral modified-release opioid products, particularly talc, may lead to serious complications if these products are parenterally abused.
AVINZA EXTENDED-RELEASE CAPSULES
Avinza extended-release capsules contain morphine sulfate in both immediate
and extended-release beads that are 1-2 mm in
diameter.13
The advantage of such a combination is that the immediate-release component
achieves plateau morphine concentrations within 30 minutes while the
extended-release component maintains these plasma concentrations throughout
the 24 hour dosing interval, which is longer than most other oral
modified-release opioid products are able to achieve. The SODAS (Spherical
Oral Drug Absorption System) is used to produce the extended-release component
of the product. The extended-release beads are prepared using sugar/starch
spheres upon which a drug/excipient layer is coated, followed by an
ammonio-methacrylate copolymer coating
(Figure 2A).
|
KADIAN SUSTAINED-RELEASE CAPSULES
Kadian sustained-release capsules contain morphine sulfate in identical
polymer-coated, sustained-release pellets; the product does not contain an
immediate-release
component.17
The pellets are similar in general structure to the extended-release beads in
Avinza (Figure 2A). However,
their polymer coating consists of an insoluble ethylcellulose base along with
polyethylene glycol (PEG) and a methacrylic acid copolymer. Both the PEG and
methacrylic acid copolymer are water soluble, but the water solubility of the
methacrylic acid copolymer is pH dependent. After ingestion, the hard gelatin
capsule shell quickly dissolves, releasing the drug-containing pellets. In the
acidic pH of the stomach, the PEG component of the polymer coating dissolves
and immediately creates pores that allow GI fluid to enter the pellets and
dissolve the morphine sulfate, which can then diffuse and be absorbed into the
body. Since only the PEG component can dissolve at that point, the pores are
relatively small, limiting drug diffusion. However, this does allow for some
drug to be absorbed quickly into the body. As the pellets enter and move
through the intestines, the pH of the GI environment continues to increase,
and the methacrylic acid copolymer begins to dissolve as the PEG continues its
dissolution. This increases the number and size of the pores in the polymer
coating, which increases the rate of morphine release.
ORAMORPH SUSTAINED-RELEASE TABLETS
Oramorph sustained-release tablets differ from Avinza and Kadian capsules
in that they contain morphine sulfate in a simple matrix system instead of a
polymer-coated reservoir (Figure
2B).19
This allows for the preparation of tablet dosage forms rather than capsules.
The drug and any additional excipients are uniformly blended with a
hydrophilic polymer (hydroxypropyl methylcellulose) and then compressed into
tablets. Upon ingestion, GI fluid penetrates the tablet and hydrates the
hydrophilic hydroxypropyl methylcellulose matrix, causing it to swell and form
a viscous gel layer. The gel layer controls both the diffusion of water into
the system and the diffusion of drug out of the system. Over time, this layer
begins to break down and dissolve. As this occurs, water penetrates deeper
into the matrix, forming a new viscous gel layer. This process continues until
the entire hydrophilic matrix is dissolved. The gel matrix effectively traps
the active ingredient and slows its release, which may occur by diffusion
through the gel layer or erosion of the gel matrix itself.
MS CONTIN CONTROLLED-RELEASE TABLETS
MS Contin controlled-release tablets contain morphine sulfate in a
dual-control polymer matrix (Contin) that consists of a hydrophilic polymer
(hydroxypropyl methylcellulose) and a hydrophobic polymer (hydroxyethyl
cellulose).19
To prepare these systems, the drug is blended with the hydrophilic polymer,
selectively hydrated with a polar solvent, and fixed with a higher aliphatic
alcohol.21
The partition coefficients of the active ingredient with the hydrophilic and
hydrophobic components of the formulation control the release of drug from the
tablet.22
The hydrophobic content is used to slow the diffusion of drug into the aqueous
phase, which limits diffusion into the GI tract and absorption into the body.
These hydrophilic/hydrophobic relationships are used to provide a more
constant and predictable release of drug from the system than that achieved
with Oramorph.
OXYCONTIN CONTROLLED-RELEASE TABLETS
OxyContin controlled-release tablets contain oxycodone HCl and are prepared
using the AcroContin delivery system, which is an improvement upon the Contin
system.12
The AcroContin system provides a biphasic absorption profile due to both an
immediate release of drug within one hour, which cannot be achieved using the
Contin system, and a prolonged release over 12 hours. This system uses a
dual-controlled matrix consisting of 2 hydrophobic polymers (ammonio
methacrylate
copolymer).3
After ingestion, the GI fluid dissolves the tablet coating, exposing the
hydrophobic acrylic matrix. An initial amount of oxycodone (
30-40% of the
respective
dose23) is
immediately released upon contact with the GI fluid, which begins channeling
into the pores of the tablet matrix. This immediate-release component is much
greater than that of Avinza (
10% of the respective
dose).20 As
GI fluid enters the tablet matrix, it dissolves the entrapped drug, which
slowly diffuses out of the matrix pores. Oxycodone release from the tablets is
pH independent, which allows for a uniform release throughout the GI tract.
Since the matrix is hydrophobic and does not dissolve, patients should be
advised that they may pass empty tablets or "ghosts" in the stool
or via colostomy, and that this is not a concern since the active ingredient
has already been released from the tablet.
PALLADONE EXTENDED-RELEASE CAPSULES
Palladone extended-release capsules were launched in February 2005 and
marketed to a limited number of medical
practitioners.24
The capsules were the first oral modified-release opioid product that
contained hydromorphone HCl. The product used an ATC (Around The Clock) matrix
pellet formulation to achieve a biphasic release of drug that resulted in a
relatively rapid rise to an initial peak concentration, followed by a second
broad peak with therapeutic plasma concentrations maintained over the 24 hour
dosing
interval.14
During product development, results indicated that consuming ethanol while
taking Palladone disrupted the modified-release mechanism of the product and
resulted in the absorption of a potentially fatal dose of
hydromorphone.24
Peak blood concentrations increased approximately 6 times with the consumption
of 8 ounces of a 40% (80 proof) ethanol solution, and approximately 2 times
with the consumption of 8 ounces of a 4% ethanol
solution.25
These results were disclosed to the Food and Drug Administration (FDA), and
Purdue had developed professional prescribing information and a patient
medication guide with strong warnings, including a boxed warning that clearly
stated the risks of consuming alcohol when taking
Palladone.24
After launching the product, Purdue monitored and collected data on medication
use, abuse, and drug diversion, which was reported to the FDA. However, in
July 2005, the FDA advised Purdue that the risk of alcohol interaction cannot
be adequately managed with warnings alone and, at the request of the FDA,
Purdue suspended all marketing and sales of
Palladone.24
The company has implemented a plan to reformulate the product to reduce the
risk of an alcohol interaction, and the FDA has agreed to consider a proposal
that would allow for the use of the drug in certain institutional settings,
such as hospitals and in-patient hospices, where access to alcohol-containing
products is controlled.
OTHER MODIFIED-RELEASE PRODUCTS
ALZA is developing an oral hydromorphone controlled-release product that
uses the OROS delivery system (Dilaudid CR) for once-daily
dosing.26
The product is currently in Phase III clinical trials. Endo has recently
received approval from the FDA for an oral oxymorphone extended-release
formulation that is to be dosed every 12
hours.27
Also, slow-release morphine sulfate or oxycodone HCl capsules that use a
drug/Methocel hypromellose matrix are often compounded by pharmacists in
certain
settings.28-30
| Clinical and Comparative Issues |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The American Pain Society states that the choice of opioid is based on the clinician's experience with an agent, since there are few data indicating a preferred agent. Clinicians also base their choice of opioid on a patient's previous experience, since some patients will tolerate or respond to particular agents better than to others.15 Because there is also a great deal of interpatient variability that may be due to genetic polymorphism, some patients may need longer or shorter dosing intervals of a modified-release opioid. This may increase costs to the patient if the interval must be decreased, resulting in more doses each day. In such cases, it may be prudent to switch the opioid to use tolerance or agents with longer half-lives (Avinza or Kadian) to decrease the pill burden and cost to the patient.
There are 3 commonly used modified-release formulations of morphine (MS Contin, Kadian, and Avinza). Kadian and Avinza have smaller trough to peak fluctuations compared with MS Contin.13,17 This means these agents have lower maximum and higher minimum concentrations than MS Contin. The clinical benefit of these pharmacokinetic differences has not correlated with higher efficacy or safety in clinical studies when Kadian or Avinza has been compared with MS Contin.32,33 It has been hypothesized that reduced fluctuations in blood morphine concentrations may influence the rate of opioid tolerance. The trough to peak fluctuation hypothesis has not been confirmed by controlled trials and should not be the reason for choosing one morphine formulation over another.
| Special Population Considerations |
|---|
|
|
|---|
PREGNANT AND BREAST-FEEDING WOMEN
All opioid analgesics reviewed here are pregnancy category C. Opioid
analgesic concentrations have been found in breast milk; therefore, the
risk/benefit of using these agents in nursing women should be considered. If
patients require chronic opioid therapy, the cessation of breast feeding may
be necessary to reduce the risk to the neonate or infant. The amount of
systemic absorption of the excipients used in preparing the modified-release
products has not been formally evaluated. Therefore, the risk of these agents
to the breast-feeding infant cannot be determined.
ELDERLY PATIENTS
Elderly patients (aged
65 y) were incorporated into the clinical
studies of the oral modified-release opioid products. However, subgroup
analysis was not possible in these trials due to small sample sizes. It is
recommended that conservative doses be initiated in these patients due to
their metabolism differences, their sensitivity to CNS active agents, and the
potential for decreased renal elimination of metabolites compared with that of
younger patients. The use of these agents is not contraindicated in this
population if appropriate monitoring and slow-dose titration are
practiced.
PATIENTS WITH PAST OR CURRENT SUBSTANCE ABUSE
Opioid products are not contraindicated in patients experiencing past or
current substance abuse if they are prescribed with the intention of treating
pain. Boundary setting, frequent assessment, and treatment plan development
are key components of opioid therapy in these patients. Boundary setting
methods include medication therapy agreements (opioid contracts) and
developing clear goals for the reduction of pain. Patients with an addictive
disorder who are experiencing chronic pain should be referred to a specialist
in pain management or addiction medicine. Opioids are used in detoxification
and maintenance programs within facilities licensed to administer these agents
to patients. All of the labeling for the oral modified-release opioid products
contains warnings and information about drug abuse and dependence.
| Summary |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||